Ranking the Fallout 3 DLC
Bethesda’s five add-ons for Fallout 3 range from a narrow combat detour to one of the best chunks of content the game ever offered, and ranking them says a lot about what makes the Capital Wasteland special.
Fallout 3 arrived in 2008, and over the following year Bethesda released five downloadable packs, later collected in the Game of the Year edition. They were made in the era when console add-ons were still finding their feet, so each one is also a small experiment in what DLC could be: a new story, a new map, a systems overhaul or a gimmick. Here they are from least to most essential.
The ranking
5. Mothership Zeta. The premise is irresistible: the player is abducted by the aliens whose crashed craft fans had been finding in the wasteland, and must fight their way off the ship with a group of fellow captives plucked from different eras. The problem is the ship itself. Corridor after metallic corridor, packed with enemies and light on choices, it plays more like a straightforward shooter than a Fallout adventure. The alien weapons are fun; the journey to them is a slog.
4. Operation Anchorage. The first pack sends the player into a military simulation of a pre-war battle in Alaska. It is linear and deliberately restrictive, with no scavenging inside the simulation, which runs against everything the main game encourages. What lifts it above Zeta are the rewards waiting outside, including a Gauss rifle and a winterised suit of power armour that changed how many players approached the rest of the game.
3. Broken Steel. The least glamorous pack and perhaps the most practical. It reworked the original ending so the story no longer simply stopped, let players keep exploring afterwards, raised the level cap from 20 to 30 and added a closing campaign against the remnants of the Enclave. For anyone who wanted more of the base game, this was the one that mattered most.
2. The Pitt. A trip to the ruins of Pittsburgh, where raiders run a brutal industrial town on slave labour. The pack is short, but it is built around a genuine moral dilemma with no clean answer, the sort of choice that sits at the heart of the series. The grimy steelworks setting and its uncomfortable ending linger long after the credits.
1. Point Lookout. A boat ride takes the player to a fog-bound coastal swampland in Maryland, a large new map with its own atmosphere, quests and folklore. Point Lookout is the closest any of the five came to the feeling of first stepping out of Vault 101: odd characters, side stories that reward wandering, and a strange, slightly eerie mood all its own. It is the pack that best understood that Fallout’s magic lies in discovery.
The pattern is telling. The weakest packs narrow the game into corridors; the best ones open it up. Years on, that is still a decent rule for judging any open-world expansion.
The problem with ever-longer games · The dilemmas of Pokémon Black and White · More games