Child of Eden and the Kinect That Could Have Been
For a brief moment in 2011, a dreamy musical shooter made the case that Kinect could be more than a party novelty, and the argument still holds up better than the hardware’s history suggests.
Microsoft launched Kinect for the Xbox 360 in late 2010 with a big promise: no controller, just your body. The early library leaned heavily on fitness, dancing and minigame collections. Some of those were fun, but few of them felt like a reason for anyone who already loved games to stand up off the sofa. Then came Child of Eden.
A spiritual successor, waved into life
Developed by Q Entertainment under Tetsuya Mizuguchi and published by Ubisoft, Child of Eden was widely seen as a spiritual successor to Rez, the 2001 rail shooter in which every shot and explosion became part of the soundtrack. The new game kept that idea of synaesthesia, sound and colour and movement fused into one experience, and set it inside a fragile digital archive of human memory that the player has to cleanse of a spreading infection.
It was playable with a standard controller, and later on PlayStation 3 with motion controls. But on Kinect it became something else. One hand swept across the screen to lock on to targets and released to fire; the other unleashed a rapid stream of shots against particular enemies. Raising both arms triggered a screen-clearing burst. Played this way, the game turned the player into something between a conductor and a painter, and the music responded to every gesture.
What made it important was not just that it worked, though it did, with a precision many Kinect titles lacked. It was that it used the body for expression rather than imitation. Most motion games asked you to mime a real activity: swing a bat, dance a routine, run on the spot. Child of Eden asked you to move in a way that had no real-world equivalent, and the controller-free input made that feel natural rather than awkward.
The road not taken
With hindsight, it is hard not to read Child of Eden as a glimpse of a path Kinect never fully followed. The camera did find an audience, and its depth-sensing technology went on to have a life well beyond games. But the hoped-for wave of ambitious, artful Kinect titles never really arrived. When the Xbox One launched in 2013 with Kinect bundled in, the device was soon made optional, and Microsoft eventually wound it down as a gaming accessory.
Mizuguchi’s ideas found other homes. The same instinct for music, light and motion later resurfaced in virtual reality, where the full-body sense of presence Child of Eden reached for became much easier to deliver. In that sense the game was not a dead end but an early sketch.
It remains one of the best arguments that motion control was never the problem in itself. The problem was imagination. Child of Eden showed what it could look like when someone brought enough of it.
The problem with ever-longer games · The dilemmas of Pokémon Black and White · More games